Arlo the Alligator Boy

Tony Hale

Teeny Tiny Tony (voice)

Jonathan Van Ness

Furlecia (voice)

Haley Tju

Alia / Rich Women (voice)

Brett Gelman

Marcellus (voice)

Flea

Ruff (voice)

Jennifer Coolidge

Stucky (voice)

Ryan Crego

Jersey Shore Guy / Mailman / Business Man / Little Bittie Louie (voice)

Dee Bradley Baker

Seagull / Purple Shirt Guy (voice)

Fred Tatasciore

Jeromio / The Beast / Muscly Farmer / Barn Folk / Doorman (voice)

Phil LaMarr

Willow Button Guy / Gill / Barn Folk / Rich Man (voice)

Eric Bauza

Bradley Alouicious / Barn Folk / Butler / Photographer (voice)

Michelle McMillan

Shirley Ray / Momma / Cabby (voice)

Judah Mackey

Sansavelt (voice)

Kat Palardy

Sandra June / NY Granny / Cat Lady (voice)

Mark Whitten

Lawrence / Barn Folk / Robber / Flyer Man / Kid Bullies (voice)

Jakari Fraser

Tourist Kid (voice)